It’s about time we discussed that tricky little bugger, fluorescence. The plethora of (often contradictive) information online, can send even the coolest of cucumbers into a tailspin. In this post, I will try to make the whole process a smidge easier, by outlining what I think are the most important points regarding fluorescence. First things first though - what in the world is ‘fluorescence’?
Fluorescence is simply the term used to describe how a diamond behaves under ultra-violet light (that blue light that makes white things appear even whiter). Just like all of our other diamond characteristics so far, fluorescence is judged on an increasing scale.
There are two ways that fluorescence can impact the visuals of your diamond. Knowing what these are and how to navigate them, will mean that you can actually use them to your advantage! The first way fluorescence can change the look of your diamond, is through the subtle blue hue the stone might emit in certain light. Fret not my internet friend, for this does not have to be a bad thing! Indeed, for some people this slight bluish tint is very appealing, and they actively seek it out.
"Indeed, for some people this slight bluish tint is very appealing, and they actively seek it out."
For others, it can be an unattractive quality (kind of like leaving the toilet seat up - not a deal breaker per se, but certainly something that needs to be modified, quick time). If you fall into the toilet seat gang (this joke is turning out a bit weird sorry1), there is a pretty cool ‘hack’ that you should know about. You see, the yellowish hue of those near-colorless diamonds (G, H, I, J and K) can often be offset by the blue undertones of the fluorescence that is present in the stone. Because of this, a ‘medium’ (and sometimes even ‘strong’) blue fluorescence can make these near-colorless diamonds appear whiter. Diamond hack!
1. I’m not sorry.
Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for colorless diamonds (D - F) especially when you move into the ‘strong’ and ‘very strong’ fluorescence side, as the yellowish hue found in near-colorless stones (that balanced out the blue) is not present in these diamonds. I would steer away from the colorless with ‘strong’, ’very strong’ fluorescence combo - unless of course that subtle blue (sometimes even violet) undertone floats your proverbial boat. In that case, go for it!
The other main worry is that a diamond with fluorescence will exhibit a milky haze. To get an understanding of what this milkiness might look like, try to visualise what happens to water when it is put in a glass that previously held milk. The water will mix with the milk residue and the color of the water will adopt a soft murky appearance, and certain strengths of fluorescence can exhibit that same look under certain circumstances, like this one on the right below;
Figure 1 Clear diamond on the left, milky/hazy diamond on the right
Now, just like our other diamond characteristics, the importance and impact of fluorescence only becomes apparent once you progress along the scale - i.e., once get to the ‘strong’ and ‘very strong’ categories. A ‘faint’ fluorescence will never appear milky or hazy for example, and even a ‘medium’ fluorescence will rarely look milky. Today however, I want to focus on the ‘strong’ and ‘very strong’ fluorescent categories. Diamonds with ‘strong’ blue fluorescence for instance, can sometimes appear slightly (or even severely) milky/hazy. Diamonds with ‘very strong’ will often have a subtle haze to them in certain lights. This point about light is crucial, because change in lighting circumstances and environment can mean a change in how the fluorescence affects the stone from moment to moment;
On the left is a diamond with ‘very strong’ fluorescence, photographed indoors. The image on the right is the same diamond, photographed in the direct sunlight. As you can see, the way the diamond is behaving in the sunlight gives it a very subtle milky look. This is not to say that this is an undesirable feature, and many people will be attracted to the almost ethereal vibe this type of stone is giving off. Indeed, the presence of ‘strong’ or even ‘very strong’ fluorescence does not mean a diamond will not be beautiful. Just look at this next example of a G color stone with ‘very strong’ fluorescence (larger stone) next to an F color ‘medium’ fluorescence (smaller stone);
This is a beautiful stone, and yet another example of how a diamond can perform very differently with a change of environment (the top left hand picture was taken indoors, the other two were taken outside). It’s also an example of why it is absolutely vital for you to be able to view your potential diamond in many different environments before you make your final commitment to your stone2.
2. Great video on the impact of very strong fluorescence in different lights; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DwpO-w-qXE
You want to be able to see what your diamond actually looks like, in the kitchen while making yummy pasta, in the living room while binge-watching House of Cards, or on the balcony while spying on your neighbours having an argument. You want to be able to examine your diamond on a beautiful sunny day, as well as a miserable wet and cloudy one.
In fact, purchasing your stone online really does give you a distinct advantage here. In a store - where the lighting is optimal (and usually there is little to no natural light coming in) - you would never be able to witness the true effect that fluorescence might have on your stone. Buying online on the other hand, means you have the luxury of checking the stone in lots of additional ways, allowing you to see how your new diamond will appear (and hopefully flourish) in its new home. And if it doesn’t, you can send it back for a refund (usually within 30 days).
Fluorescence does impact price, and not just in the way you would assume (the stronger the fluorescence the cheaper the stone). In reality it’s a little more complicated than that. Let’s us look at this picture to get to the bottom of it:
Figure 2 The brighter the diamond appears under UV light (top row), the higher the fluorescence
When it comes to color (top row), these diamonds look pretty different right? You might be interested to know that all of these stones are graded ‘I’ color, even though stones 2, 4 and 6 in particular actually have a much yellower hue to them than the others. It is no coincidence also that these are the stones with the strongest fluorescence. Their fluorescence has masked their "true" color and made them appear whiter that they actually are. Here is how that could have happened.
When diamonds are graded for color, they are done so indoors, under conditions of artificial lighting (and often very near UV lights which will further enhance their whiteness). This increases the probability of mistakenly ‘over-grading’ fluorescent diamonds for color, typically giving them higher color grades due to the fluorescence essentially hiding the yellowish hues of the stones. Indeed, a good proportion of the color ‘over-grading’ mistakes are associated with fluorescence.
For this reason, diamonds with strong fluorescence tend to be traded at a discount of 10-15% to allow for any potential grading mistakes. How fluorescence affects price then, is not necessarily about the look of the stone (trends and tastes for and against fluorescent diamonds change over time), but instead it is about how a diamond might be over-graded and thus over-priced, relative to the actual characteristics of the stone itself.
This leaves you with a great way to reduce the cost of your diamond, especially if you are willing to take a chance on a fluorescent diamond. As we have seen above, not only can fluorescent diamonds be absolutely beautiful but they are a fantastic way to save some money if you know how to work the system - leaving you more cash to splash on that dream ring setting. Hurrah!