Rare Carat is rated 5/5 on Trustpilot (2,000+ reviews), while Brilliant Earth sits at 4.2/5 with 18% of customers leaving 1-star reviews (as of April 2026). Rare Carat offers over 1,700 ring styles in various precious metals, often at more competitive prices. Many customers who were disappointed with Brilliant Earth's collection found exactly what they were looking for at Rare Carat.
![]()